Why Stillness Can Feel Uncomfortable at First

On Rest, Stillness & Return

Stillness is often imagined as peaceful.

It's associated with calm, clarity, and rest — a state we assume will feel relieving once we finally reach it. And yet, when people actually slow down, many are surprised to find that stillness feels anything but comfortable.

Instead of ease, there is restlessness.

Instead of quiet, there is noise.

Instead of relief, there is tension.

This can be confusing.

If stillness is supposed to help, why does it sometimes feel so difficult to remain there? Why does the body fidget, the mind race, the impulse to move or distract grow stronger the longer nothing is happening?

The discomfort is not a sign that stillness is failing.

It is a sign that stillness is honest.

Most of life is lived in motion. Even when we appear to be resting, we are often consuming, processing, responding, or planning. Movement keeps certain things at bay. It gives the inner life somewhere to direct its attention. When movement stops, attention turns inward — and what it finds is not always immediately pleasant.

Stillness removes the buffers.

Without activity to absorb awareness, the mind begins to surface what has been postponed. Thoughts that were held at a distance drift closer. Emotions that were muted by busyness become more noticeable. The nervous system, long accustomed to stimulation or vigilance, struggles to recognize quiet as safe.

This reaction is deeply human.

For many people, stillness has been absent not because they avoided it, but because their lives required readiness. Responsibility, care, uncertainty, and pressure teach the inner life to stay alert. Over time, that alertness becomes habitual. When stillness finally arrives, the system doesn't know how to receive it.

So it resists.

The body may feel tense.

The mind may search for problems to solve.

The urge to check, do, or fix may intensify.

This resistance can feel like failure, especially for those who associate stillness with spiritual maturity or emotional health. People may assume they are doing something wrong, that they lack discipline or depth, that they should be able to settle more easily.

But stillness is not a skill that activates instantly.

It is a condition that must be trusted.

Trust takes time to rebuild.

Stillness asks the inner life to believe that nothing bad will happen if it stops scanning, planning, or managing. For a system that has learned safety through activity, this belief does not come easily. The discomfort is not opposition — it is caution.

In this sense, restlessness in stillness is a form of communication.

It signals that something has been carried for a long time. That there are concerns waiting to be acknowledged. That the inner life is not yet convinced it can rest without consequence. Trying to silence this response quickly often increases the discomfort.

What helps instead is permission.

Permission to let stillness feel awkward.

Permission to let thoughts arise without chasing them.

Permission to notice discomfort without labeling it as failure.

When stillness is approached gently, the inner life begins to soften. Not all at once, and not predictably. But gradually, as nothing terrible happens, trust grows. The nervous system learns that quiet does not require immediate response.

This learning is subtle.

It happens in brief moments — a breath that deepens without effort, a thought that passes without being followed, a sense of presence that lingers for a few seconds longer than before. These moments are not dramatic, but they matter.

They teach the inner life that stillness is not an absence of safety, but a different form of it.

It's also important to recognize that stillness does not mean emptiness.

Stillness is full of sensation, memory, and awareness. When people first encounter it, they are often surprised by how much is there. This fullness can feel overwhelming at first, especially if it has been avoided or postponed for a long time.

But fullness is not the same as overload.

Over time, as attention becomes less reactive, what once felt crowded begins to feel spacious. Thoughts lose urgency. Emotions move more freely. Silence becomes less threatening, not because everything has resolved, but because nothing is being resisted as strongly.

This transition cannot be rushed.

Trying to force stillness into comfort turns it back into a task. The goal is not to achieve a particular state, but to remain present with whatever arises. Comfort is a byproduct, not a requirement.

If stillness feels uncomfortable to you, it does not mean you are unsuited for it. It means you are encountering it honestly. You are noticing what has been waiting beneath motion.

You don't need to stay still for long.

You don't need to make it peaceful.

You don't need to quiet everything that appears.

It is enough to remain for a moment longer than feels easy, without judgment. To allow discomfort to exist without fleeing it. To trust that the inner life knows how to settle when it feels safe enough to do so.

Stillness becomes gentler with familiarity.

What feels exposed at first often becomes grounding.

What feels restless often becomes responsive.

What feels uncomfortable often becomes revealing.

Stillness is not meant to be forced into serenity. It is meant to be entered with patience. The discomfort that arises is not a barrier to stillness — it is part of the threshold.

And thresholds, by nature, feel unfamiliar before they feel like home.

If you'd like to receive an occasional letter like this, you're welcome to subscribe.